Suspect’s Miranda Rights Not Violated When He Volunteered Statements About His Killing Another.

Our clients frequently tell us that when they were arrested, police never “read them their rights.” This is a reference to one’s Miranda rights, which movies and television frequently show being read to a suspect at the earliest stages of an arrest. In other words, the client is telling us that his or her arrest was not like in the movies or on television.

Sometimes, this matters. Sometimes it does not. In the following case, it did not matter.

Thomas Kemp kidnapped Hector Juarez, used Juarez’s ATM card to withdraw $200 from Juarez’s bank account and then used a .380 handgun to shoot Juarez twice in the head, killing him. Kemp then made two more attempts to use Juarez’s ATM card, but could not remember the PIN number.

Kemp then repainted his truck a different color and drove to Flagstaff, Arizona, where he bought a second .380 handgun. While in Arizona, he met a couple who was driving to Kansas. Kemp then kidnapped them and forced them to drive him to Colorado. While in a hotel room in Colorado, Kemp forced the man to disrobe and sexually assaulted him.

The next morning, the group drove to Denver, at which time the couple escaped Kemp. Kemp was soon thereafter arrested and taken to the county jail. When arrested, he was read his Miranda rights. Kemp then answered some questions from the police before stopping and asking for a lawyer. At one point in the questioning, he commented, “I guess my life is over now.”

While in jail, he asked a police officer there to be transferred from the general population pod to a different pod “because the guy I killed was Mexican” and “all the Mexicans in my pod are after me.” Another officer then asked Kemp to restate why he wanted the transfer and Kemp answered that he had killed a Hispanic man and the Hispanic inmates thought it was racially motivated. He voluntarily explained that he wanted to be moved “for my own protection.”

Kemp was thereafter charged, convicted and sentenced for first-degree murder, armed robbery and kidnapping and, due to the aggravating factors, sentenced to death. Kemp had been previously convicted of a violent felony. While on death row, he filed a habeas petition, arguing that his Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights were violated when officers asked him questions and his statements were later admitted at trial. He claimed that his confession was coerced.

The district court denied his petition, finding that there was no “interrogation” as defined under Miranda v. Arizona (1966) 384 U.S. 436. The district court characterized the statements as informal, initiated by Kemp and not intended by police to elicit incriminating responses. The court commented that the police questions were routine in nature, reasonable and only sought information to protect Kemp, not prosecute him.

Kemp then appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. In its decision (Thomas Arnold Kemp v. Charles L. Ryan (2011 DJDAR 5985)), the court described the jailhouse conversation between Kemp and the guards as “ordinary, everyday interaction.” There was no indicia of an interrogation.

Moreover, the court noted that “interrogation . . . must reflect a measure of compulsion above and beyond that inherent in custody itself.” Applying this to Kemp’s statements and the officer’s inquiries, the court found that their inquiry was not “deliberately designed to elicit incriminating remarks.”

As such, the lower court’s denial of Kemp’s motion was affirmed.

Greg Hill is a criminal defense attorney in Torrance, California. He graduated from the U.S. Naval Academy (Bachelor of Science, 1987), Boston University (M.B.A. 1994) and Loyola Law School (J.D. 1998). Visit his firm’s website is at http://www.greghillassociates.com or call him at (310) 782-2500.

Greg Hill is a criminal defense attorney in Torrance, California. He graduated from the U.S. Naval Academy (Bachelor of Science, 1987), Boston University (M.B.A. 1994) and Loyola Law School (J.D. 1998). Visit his firm’s website is at http://www.greghillassociates.com or call him at (310) 782-2500.

Author Bio: Greg Hill is a criminal defense attorney in Torrance, California. He graduated from the U.S. Naval Academy (Bachelor of Science, 1987), Boston University (M.B.A. 1994) and Loyola Law School (J.D. 1998). Visit his firm’s website is at http://www.greghillassociates.com or call him at (310) 782-2500.

Category: Legal
Keywords: Greg Hill,Attorney,Torrance,Lawyer,Criminal Defense,Fifth Amendment,Long Beach,Los Angeles

Leave a Reply